Dear Ned Colletti,
I've been curious about the front office's lack of movement in trying to build our pitching staff. It's not that I don't have faith in our current roster...it's just well...
Let me take a step back.
We don't have a Chris Carpenter. We don't have a Roy Halladay. We don't have a Tim Lincecum, Cliff Lee, or Josh Beckett. We don't have an ace.
That isn't a bad thing. We have a compelation of talent that is collectively effective. We have Chad Billingsley and Clayton Kershaw, young guns who are still finding their groove. When they're on, they're on. We have Hiroki Kuroda and Randy Wolf, who will consistently keep the team in the game. We have Ramon Troncoso, James MacDonald, Guillermo Mota, Ronald Bellisario, Brent Leach and Hong Chi Kuo- a great but overused bullpen we can rely on. We have George Sherrill and Jonathan Broxton, lights-out closers who we use in our final innings.
But Kuroda will miss his next start due to a line drive to the head. Who knows what he’ll give us when he goes back out on the mound? Billingsley’s been out because of his hamstring, and how sure are we he’ll be back at 100%? Kershaw is young. I think fans forget this kid is only 21 years old, and this is his first full season as a starter. Sure he’s on when he’s on, but he’s still young and figuring out his arm.
Where does that leave us? Randy Wolf? He’s been pitching very consistently lately, but he’s a 6-7 innings guy. And we haven’t had a fifth starter since the beginning of the season! Because of this, our bullpen is overworked and overused, increasing their collective ERA from around 2.5 in June to over 4 now in August. And our closer, Jonathan Broxton, has eight wins. A closer shouldn’t have that many wins, and that was 8 in the beginning of July. Broxton’s been slumping lately, and he’s still working through it.
Mr. Coletti, the last time I checked, we’re here for a pennant race. We’ve been to the NLDS. We’ve been to the NLCS. We’ve tasted victory and went home with defeat. The last time the Dodgers held a World Series title was in 1988. It’s been 21 years, and if there’s a year where the players and fans could see it, this is the year.
But we need pitching. Our offense can only take us so far.
Ok, so you didn’t jump after Roy Halladay. That’s ok, no one else did, and he’s still in Toronto. I still think that was a mistake, seeing as the Blue Jays were ok with not trading for Billingsley and Kershaw. Yeah, we would have had to give up our top prospects, but we would’ve gotten Halladay for two years, and when he’s a free agent, we would have gotten top draft picks. Ok, so you didn’t jump after Cliff Lee, the Phillies did. That’s
not ok. He’s 3-0 as a Philly with a 1.13 ERA. To get to the World Series we have to get through the Phillies. Sure, we took the season series against them, but that was without Lee, without a hot J.A. Happ, and with a slumping Cole Hamels, Ryan Howard and Jimmy Rollins.
The Red Sox just released John Smoltz. I know the Dodgers are considering him, but are worried about his shoulder. Here’s my take: just sign him. The Red Sox are required to pay the rest of his contract, it would only cost LA $500,000 to sign him right away. It wouldn’t cost us anything, seeing as we saved money from Manny Ramirez’s suspension.
The Dodgers can afford to be patient with Smoltz. The Red Sox couldn’t. The Sox are involved in a very heated Wild Card race, and had no room to let an old dog rest his arm. The Dodgers, on the other hand, just need help to maintain the lead in the NL West until our pitching staff regains its composure. Throw Smoltz in the bullpen. What’s the worse that could happen?
Ok, so our starting rotation can only give us 6 innings. Throw Smoltz in the 7th, Sherril in the 8th, and then Broxton if you need to in the 9th. What do you have to lose right now? Give Kuo, Troncoso and the guys some rest. Smoltz is a veteran player, so even if he doesn’t throw lights out, he can teach the young guys a thing or two about how it’s like in the post season.
And we can’t forget the human element.
John Smoltz will have something to prove. He’s said he’s not ready to retire. He’s said he’s not done throwing. Sign him, and see what he can do.
Until then, Mr. Coletti, whether you decide to move or not, I and countless other Dodger fans are crossing our fingers and holding our breath until October.
-Jamie